Found a black widow in my bed
Now I'm stressin' out 'bout what it meant
Feeling like I'm hangin' by a thread
Why'd you have to leave me left on read?
Everything is fuckin' with my head
Every little thing we left unsaid
I can see it start to manifest
Exactly like my psychic said

That little black cat ain't bringin' you back
Ain't bringin' you back

I wanna believe
The universe has to know
When you comin' back
When you're walkin' through the door
I'm lookin' for metaphors
Ain't none of this rational
But neither are we, we supernatural

Superstitious like Stevie
My horiscope told me that you wanted to see me
4 AM in the back of the black car, speedin'
Amethyst on the dash in the HOV lane
Full Moon lightin' up your exit, 3A
You open up the door, my bad, I know you're sleepin'
If I said I needed love, love, would you believe me?
If I said I needed love, love, would you believe me?
That little black cat ain't bringin' you back (hey, hey)
Ain't bringin' you back

I wanna believe
The universe has to know
When you comin' back
When you're walkin' through the door
I'm lookin' for metaphors
Ain't none of this rational
But neither are we, we supernatural

If we break up during the eclipse
Then we gotta get our shit together by the sixth
You did our numerology and shit
I'm a three, you a twenty-two, let's have a kid
We be on that woo-woo
I want to get onto Honolulu and have you kiss my booboo
Hold me when I boo-hoo, watch a little Hulu
And split me in two, two like zooma, zooma, zoom, zoom

That little ain't bringin' you back (zoom, zoom)
Ain't bringin' you back

I wanna believe (I wanna believe)
The universe has to know (it has to know)
When you comin' back (when you comin' back)
When you're walkin' through the door (through the door)
I'm lookin' for metaphors (for metaphors)
Ain't none of this rational (rational)
But neither are we, we supernatural, yeah

That little black cat ain't bringin' you back
Ain't bringin' you back (no, no, no, no)
That little black cat ain't bringin' you back (oh, oh)
Ain't bringin' you back (I wanna believe)
That little black cat ain't bringin' you back (natural)
Ain't bringin' you back
I wanna believe that we supernatural